Meet Your Account Managers

Our regional Account Managers are here to serve you and help you grow your book of business. Learn more about them here.

Northeast Ohio: Amanda Mcfarland

Amanda Mcfarland

Amanda Mcfarland is the account manager for northeast Ohio, supporting the Medicare and Individual and Family markets. Amanda has been with Medical Mutual since 2015. Prior to Medical Mutual, Amanda worked at Anthem Blue Cross Blue Shield in a similar role for nearly ten years. She enjoys working at Medical Mutual because of the local employees and her ability to talk to decision makers directly. Her favorite part of her job is working alongside brokers, whose relationships have turned in to friendships over the years. Amanda enjoys meeting new agents and growing their relationships as well as their book of business.

When away from the office, Amanda is often at the field with her husband, Jacob, watching their triplets, Mackenzie, Mason and Maxim, play baseball and softball. In between family and work time, she volunteers as the Outreach Director at Mosaic Church in Wadsworth.

Contact Amanda to learn more about Medical Mutual.


Phone: 440-572-6367

Northwest and Central Ohio: Mike Broderick

Mike Broderick

Mike Broderick has been with Medical Mutual since 2012, working as an Account Manager for the Toledo and Columbus area, northwest Ohio, central Ohio and some parts of southern Ohio. He supports the Medicare and Individual and Family markets.

Mike grew up in Brooklyn and Long Island, New York before heading to the Midwest and attending Ohio State University. Prior to joining Medical Mutual, Mike held a similar role with Assurant Health, focusing on the Individual and Small Group markets.

At Medical Mutual, Mike enjoys working for an Ohio-based company focused on improving Ohioans’ lives with quality healthcare coverage. He values the teamwork and comradery he shares with other employees. Mike also enjoys working alongside brokers in northwest Ohio and helping them grow their agencies.

Away from the office, you can find Mike spending time with his wife Dawn, daughter Caitlyn and stepson Zac. He also enjoys spending time with colleagues from work and friends from college. In between work and family time, Mike volunteers at the Saint Vincent DePaul Society through St. Margaret’s church. He also enjoys attending sporting events and concerts.

Contact Mike to learn more about Medical Mutual.


Phone: 419-595-6366

Southwest Ohio: Jennifer Detrick-Myers

Jennifer Detrick-Myer

Jennifer Detrick-Myers is the Medical Mutual account manager for southwest Ohio, supporting the Medicare and Individual and Family markets. Jennifer is originally from the Dayton area, where she worked on both the wholesale and retail side of the business marketing group, including Individual and Medicare products. In years prior to joining Medical Mutual, she served as part of the large group account team for Premier Health Plan working with clients, agents, and brokers in southwest Ohio.

Jennifer enjoys working for a company that serves the needs of Ohioans. Being part of the Medical Mutual team also allows her to reconnect with agents she’s worked with previously.

Away from the office, you can find Jennifer and her husband Joe at the lake with their children Jamie, Ben and Jen, as well as with their three grandchildren Tristan, Annabell and Easton. Her family also enjoys spending time with their church community at Victory Church in Tipp City where Jennifer and her husband are active volunteers.

Please contact Jennifer to learn more about how Medical Mutual can benefit your clients.


Phone: 513-684-8199